We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. Why trust us?

10 Best Mattress Protectors, According to Bedding Experts

Protect and extend the lifespan of your mattress.

Best Mattress Protectors, According to Bedding Experts

We updated this article in January 2022 to remove an unavailable item and to include new picks from Avocado Green Mattress and Turmerry.

After finding your dream mattress, you may think the next step is putting on your sheets. But first, you should really consider adding a mattress protector. Mattress protectors are worth it because they're designed to extend the life of your mattress by acting as the first line of defense against wear and tear, allergens (like pet dander and pollen), spills and even bed bugs. Best of all, while cleaning your mattress is difficult, you can wash a mattress protector by tossing it into the washing machine. When accidents inevitably happen, you will be counting your lucky stars that you invested in a mattress protector before the damage.

The Good Housekeeping Institute Textiles Lab tests hundreds of bedding products each year, from sheets to comforters to pillows to mattresses. Our expertise means we can identify great mattress protectors: Our picks have either excellent laboratory performance or rave reviews and innovative features from trusted brands to help build your ultimate bed.

What is the best type of mattress protector?

  • Five-sided protectors go on your mattress like a fitted sheet. This protector does not cover the mattress entirely, so it cannot protect against bed bugs. But because it’s easier to take on and off, it’s a great pick for easy clean up from incontinence or frequent spills.
  • Encasement protectors cover the entire mattress and have a zipper closure to keep them secure. Encasement styles are the mattress protectors to guard against bed bugs, but they're more difficult to remove for washing.

    Want easy cleanup and bed bug protection? Layer an encasement protector over the mattress and then add a five-sided protector on top for the best of both worlds. And if you're worried about frequent spills and accidents, make sure you invest in a truly waterproof mattress protector. These are the best mattress protectors, according to our Lab pros:

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
    Best Encasement Mattress Protector
    Zippered Waterproof Mattress Encasement

    • Over 35,000 rave Amazon reviews
    • Pillow and box spring encasements available
    • Full mattress protection

    • Compare the size chart closely to your mattress size to prevent tears

    Amazon's most popular mattress protector is this Linenspa waterproof encasement style for ultimate protection. The mattress protector zippers around the mattress with hooded Velcro flaps for the zipper to tuck into, creating a tight seal resistant to bed bugs. If you suffer from allergies, this pick can create a guard against household allergens like dust mites, pet dander and pollen. We love that they also offer pillow and box spring encasements too.

    • Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Full XL, Queen, Split Queen, King and Cal King; box spring and pillow encasement options.
    : Polyester with polyurethane
    : Yes

    Best 5-Sided Mattress Protector
    Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress Protector

    • Over 210,000 rave reviews
    • Made with cotton
    • Easy to put on and take off

    • Cannot protect against bed bugs

    With a whopping 210,000 reviews (!!!) and a 4.6-star rating on Amazon, this mattress protector from SafeRest comes highly recommended. It features a soft cotton terry top layer with a waterproof backing without vinyl, designed to be noiseless. As a five-sided style, it's easy to put on the bed like a fitted sheet.

    Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King and Cal King
    Materials: Cotton terry with membrane backing
    Waterproof: Yes

    Best Value Mattress Protector
    Zippered Mattress Protector
    Utopia Bedding
    Utopia Bedding
    Now 12% off

    • Starts at just $17 for Twin size
    • Stretchy polyester fabric for easy set up
    • 360-degree zippered protection

    • Some reviewers note it's noisy

    Starting at just $17 for a Twin size, this pick provides full encasement, waterproof protection for a fraction of the cost of other picks. With waterproof backing, the top of this protector is designed to be comfy while still repelling liquids. Plus, it is completely machine washable for easy care.

    Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King and Cal King
    Materials: Polyester
    Waterproof: Yes

    Best Mattress Protector for Bed Bugs
    Encasement Mattress Protector

    • Extra small zippers and Velcro coverings
    • OEKO TEX certified
    • Multiple depth options

    • Warranty differs with Amazon purchases

    SafeRest's encasement protector can guard against bed bugs. Using extra small zippers and Velcro coverings, this protector is designed to keep pesky bed bugs or dust mites out of your bed. Plus, this pick is OEKO TEX certified, so you can be confident it is free from dangerous amounts of harmful substances.

    Sizes: Crib, Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King and Cal King with depth options up to 18"
    Materials: Cotton terry with membrane backing
    Waterproof: Yes

    Best Mattress Protector for Every Size Bed
    Encasement Mattress Protector
    SureGuard Mattress Protectors
    Now 27% off

    • Available in Crib to California King sizes
    • Soft cotton terrycloth
    • Quiet waterproof backing

    • Some reviewers note that's not fully waterproof against large amounts of fluid

    Your mattress protector must fit your mattress for it to do its job properly and be quiet and comfy while you sleep. This encasement style waterproof protector by SureGuard offers multiple sizes from crib to California King with different mattress depths, keeping your mattress clean no matter its size.

    Sizes: Crib, Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King and Cal King with depth options up to 20"
    Materials: Cotton terry with membrane backing
    Waterproof: Yes

    Best Cooling Mattress Protector
    Core Mattress Protector

    • Outlast cooling technology
    • Waterproof backing
    • 60-night sleep trial

    • Most expensive pick

    The main caveat of waterproof materials is they can sometimes cause the mattress to get a bit hot. Slumbercloud designed the Dryline Mattress Protector with Outlast coating technology, which stores and releases heat to keep you at a comfortable temperature all night long. Featured previously as our best temperature regulating sheets, SlumberCloud is a great pick for your ultimate cool bed.

    Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King and Cal King
    Materials: Tencel outer cover with Outlast technology and a membrane backing
    : Yes

    Best Organic Mattress Protector
    Organic Waterproof Mattress Protector
    Avocado Green Mattress
    Avocado Green Mattres

    • Accommodates mattresses 6" to 16" in depth
    • Reviewers rave that it's nearly noise free
    • GREENGUARD Gold certified for low emissions

    • Some reviewers wish it had a tighter fit to the mattress

    While most mattress protectors aren't available with organic materials, this pick from Avocado Green Mattress is made with GOTS certified organic cotton. It features two layers of organic cotton surrounding a thin polyurethane waterproof film to protect against spills. The protector goes on like a fitted sheet for easy on/off.

    Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King and Cal King
    Materials: Organic cotton with polyurethane waterproof layer
    : Yes

    Best Crib Mattress Protector
    Waterproof Fitted Crib Protective Mattress Pad Cover
    American Baby Company
    American Baby Company

    • Easy to take off
    • Fluffy quilted top
    • Over 32,000 rave Amazon reviews

    • Some reviewers note pilling after washing

    Before potty training, diaper leaks are inevitable, but a mattress protector prevents nighttime leaks from ruining the mattress in your baby's crib. With over 32,000 Amazon reviews and a 4.7-star rating, this pick is 5-sided, so it's easy to take off in case of an accident. It is designed to fit the standard crib mattress size (28" x 52" x 9"). Reviewers also loved to use this mattress protector on dog beds too!

    Sizes: Mini Crib, Crib and Playard
    Materials: Polyester
    : Yes

    Quietest Mattress Protector
    Organic Cotton Waterproof Mattress Protector Cover

    • Organic materials
    • Super quiet waterproof backing
    • Large range of sizes available

    • Not designed for bed bug protection

    This topper features organic cotton jersey fabric with a waterproof backing that's waterproof without any crinkling noises. When evaluating in the Lab, our pros were impressed at just how quiet this pick is without major off-gassing smells common with mattress protectors. With Crib, Twin XL and Split Cal King sizes included, this pick has a great variety of size options.

    Sizes: Crib, Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King and Split Cal King
    Materials: Organic cotton with polyurethane backing
    : Yes

    Best Mattress Protector for College Dorms
    Student Bedding Protection Kit
    Now 13% off

    • Full 3-piece set with everything a college student needs
    • Encasement protects against bed bugs
    • 5-sided protector guards against spills

    • Not available with Prime shipping

    At college, you will be sleeping on a used mattress, so you want as much protection as possible. This pick is a 3-piece set, including an encasement mattress protector, a 5-sided protector and a pillow protector. The encasement protector will act as a barrier from bed bugs and other pests or allergens while the basic protector is waterproof for easy clean up from accidental spills. This set will help you sleep soundly on an unfamiliar mattress.

    Sizes: Twin XL
    Materials: Polyester
    : Yes

    This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io
    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
    More From Home Products